Showing posts with label israel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label israel. Show all posts

Yad L'Achim Exposed - Parts II & III

Apr 5, 2011 at 3:06 PM

Last Thursday I posted a link to the first part of a special investigative report aired on Israel's Channel 1 News about the anti-missionary organization, Yad L'Achim. The group is responsible for regular acts of harassment and violence against religious minorities in Israel, especially Messianic Jews.

This three part special report is an important step for religious rights in Israel, particularly with raising awareness toward Messianic Jews. Here are the second and third parts which have now aired:

Part II



Part III



Yad L'Achim Exposed

Mar 31, 2011 at 9:18 PM

This last week Israel's Channel 1 News aired a special investigative report on the anti-missionary organization, Yad L'Achim. The group is responsible for regular acts of harassment and violence against religious minorities in Israel, especially Messianic Jews. There is even a link between Yad L'Achim and the Jewish terrorist Jack Teitell who is currently being held for multiple acts of hate and violence, including planting the bomb that nearly killed a young Messianic Jewish teenager.

Along with the growth and influence of Yad L'Achim in recent years, there has also been an increase in its chutzpah. It is now taking upon itself to stalk and harass Israeli citizens who are not even connected to a religious minority.

The most telling part of the video is Yad L'Achim's founder, Rabbi Dov Lipshitz, responding to the inquiries of the reporter with the comment:

"The government is using democracy in order to not do what it is supposed to do. They need to decide if this is a Jewish country or a democracy. But they don't always go together - They are not friends."

And all of this is with the full support if Israel's Ministry of Interior. Many Israelis are joining with the voices of Israel's Messianic Jews and others in speaking out against this hate-group.

Watch the Channel 1 News special report here:



Harassment in Arad

Mar 20, 2011 at 9:19 PM

A couple of weeks ago I blogged about the
hate-fest in Ashdod directed against Messianic Jews in the city. Recently, similar protests have been held in another Israeli city, Arad. Going back to 2006, Arad has been the location of many violent acts directed against Messianic Jews, especially by the Gur Chassidim. Messianic Jews have been harassed, fired from their jobs, physically attacked, and protested against. This is despite the fact that Messianic Jews are faithful citizens, contribute to the greater good of the country, serve in elite military units, own businesses, and even serve in the government.


Yet, there are individuals and groups within Israel who violently oppose Messianic Jews. Below is a recent news segment from Israel's Channel 1 News on the demonstrations in Arad directed toward Messianic Jews:




Hate-Fest in Ashdod

Feb 27, 2011 at 10:38 PM


Persecution against Messianic Jews has increased lately in Israel, and last Monday night, February 21st, nearly 1,000 protesters gathered outside a Messianic congregation in Ashdod to spew vicious hatred and lies. The event was organized by Yad L'Achim and was attended by many well-known rabbis who participated in delivering virulent speeches - spewing the typical epithets that Messianic Jews steal Jewish souls, prey on children, and equating us with Hitler. The following quote is taken from an eye witness to the events as they unfolded:

"Before I realized what was happening I had between 50-100 people surrounding me, calling me a missionary and asking me what I was doing in Israel. Boys as young as 6-7 years old were hissing at me, making hateful faces. The group closed in more and more trying to intimidate and I'll be honest it worked.

There was a heavy police presence in the area, but it took the police a while to notice (or want to notice) that suddenly I had become a topic of interest to many in the crowd …

The spirit of hate, the demonic spirit that just radiated off of them is hard to put into words. I tried to look some in the eyes, but I found only a cold, death-like gaze staring back at me.

After about 15 minutes of the crowd getting closer and closer and becoming more and more vocal, I knew it was time to go. I asked a police officer to escort me to my car and then left.

I felt so sick to my stomach. I wasn't really afraid. I was honestly just so sad. These are my fellow Jews, my fellow Israelis, my family ... and they wanted to kill me. I'm convinced that if the police had not been there, they would have tried."

We must pray, speak-up, and stand together with our holy brothers and sisters in Eretz Yisrael who are at the forefront and paving the way for the rest of us.

Update: Tomorrow, Tuesday, March 1st, hundreds of Ultra-Orthodox protesters are expected to stage a similar protest in Arad. Messianic Jews in that city have faced violent persecution for years. Please pray for the safety of our fellow Messianic Jews in Arad ... and we'll keep you posted.


Egypt, Israel, and the Meneptah Stele

Feb 9, 2011 at 2:29 PM

Egypt plays a central role throughout the Bible, and particularly in the foundational narratives of Joseph, the Israelite enslavement, and the Exodus of the Israelites. With the influence these narratives have on the shaping of not only of Judaism and the Jewish people, but on western culture and religion as a whole, one would expect to find ample evidence for the existence of Israel in Egypt during the Bronze Age. Yet, despite the centrality of these events, there is no direct evidence outside of the Bible to support the existence of Israel in Egypt.

However, as has often been noted, the absence of evidence is not necessarily evidence of absence. There is much that is absent from the historical record in Egypt. Furthermore, there is actually indirect support for the existence of Semitic peoples and influence in Egypt during the Bronze Age that may or may not corroborate the accounts recorded in the biblical text. This indirect support includes the Amarna letters, Tale of Two Brothers, Papyrus Harris, Beni Hassan tomb, Karnak reliefs, possibly the stele of Ramesses II, and various scarabs and inscriptions.

Although this evidence does not directly support the accounts recorded in the Biblical text, they do help establish credence for some historical details that may have been retained in the collective memory of Israel and later recorded in the Biblical accounts.[1]

EGYPTIAN EVIDENCE FOR ISRAEL

The issue of direct evidence all changes by Iron Age I, when the Israelites (or proto-Israelites)[2] are already settling in Canaan.

During this period we begin to find direct archaeological evidence for the existence of a particular people group, the early Israelites, in the central Judean hills, and the development of a uniquely ‘proto-Israelite’ material culture;[3] which includes enclosed settlements with ‘Four Roomed Houses,’ collared rimed pottery, hewn cisterns, terraced farming, and other material culture in addition to a unique ideology.

This is important because it establishes the reality of a people known as the Israelites in Canaan by the 1200’s BCE. Furthermore, cultures do not crop up overnight. So if one can find direct evidence for Israel in Iron I, it is quite plausible to assume the existence of the Israelites at least back into the Late Bronze Age.

MERNEPTAH STELE

The earliest and most direct reference we have to Israel outside the biblical narrative is the Victory Stele of the 19th Dynasty Egyptian king Merneptah.[4] Also known as the “Israel Stele,” it was erected in Thebes around 1210 BCE and records the victorious exploits of an Egyptian military campaign in Canaan, and lists specific enemies that were defeated. The Merneptah Stele is a black granite slab over 7.5 feet high,[5] and was discovered in 1896 in an expedition led by early archaeologist, Sir William Flinders Petrie. The particularly relevant portion of the Stele reads:

Plundered is Canaan with every evil;

Carried off is Ashkelon; seized upon is Gezer;

Yanoam is made as that which does not exist;

Israel is laid waste, his seed is not;

Hurru is become a widow for Egypt!

All lands together, they are pacified.[6]

Whether the events described are fictive or real, what is clear is that by the 13th century BCE, a people called Israel existed, and that the king of Egypt not only knew about them, but felt it was worth boasting about their defeat.[7]

Additionally, the specific way Israel is mentioned is also significant. According to Hershel Shanks, “Unpronounced signs, called determinatives, attached to the place names in this section of the stele indicate that Ashkelon, Gezer and Yonoam were cities and that Canaan was a foreign land; the determinative for Israel, however, indicates that the term referred to a people rather than a place.”[8]

Archaeologist William Dever further explains[9] that the existence of the Merneptah Stele is of extreme importance and tells us four things:

  1. By 1210 BCE there existed in Canaan a cultural and political entity called “Israel” that was known to the Egyptians by that name.
  2. Israel was well enough established to be perceived as a threat.
  3. This Israel did not comprise of an organized state like others in Canaan, but was considered a loosely affiliated people group.
  4. Israel was not located in the lowlands, but in the more remote central hill region.

In summary, the Merneptah Stele contains a wealth of information, and is the earliest evidence we have outside the Bible for the existence of a people known as Israel in the 13th century BCE.





[1] Baruch Halpern, "The Exodus from Egypt: Myth or Reality?" The Rise of Ancient Israel (Washington, DC: Biblical Archaeology Society, 1992), 89-91.

[2] William G. Dever, Who Were the Early Israelites and Where Did They Come From? (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003), 194-200.

[3] William G. Dever, “How to Tell an Israelite from a Canaanite.” The Rise of Ancient Israel (Washington, DC: Biblical Archaeology Society, 1992), 30.

[4] William G. Dever, What Did the Biblical Writers Know and When Did They Know It (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2001), 118.

[5] Hershel Shanks, “Defining the Problems.” The Rise of Ancient Israel (Washington, DC: Biblical Archaeology Society, 1992), 17.

[6] James B. Pritchard, Ed. The Ancient Near East (Princeton Press, 1973), 231.

[7] Ibid. Shanks, “Defining the Problems,” 18.

[8] Ibid. 18.

[9] Ibid. 206.


Quote of the Day

Jun 11, 2010 at 10:59 AM

Rabbi David Nesenoff, the rabbi who interviewed Helen Thomas, has received thousands of hate messages following the release of the video showing Thomas making anti-Israel and anti-Jewish comments. You can read some of the hate mail on his website, Rabbilive.com.

Our Quote of the Day is from an article posted today on Haaretz.com:

"According to Nesenoff, he no longer sees a difference between anti-Semitic and anti-Israel behavior, saying that Israel was "a legitimate state and if there's any criticism it must be specific. But people keep returning to the question: Why are the Jews living there? They took over that country.' It is a re-writing of history while ignoring the centuries-long Jewish presence in Israel. Those are statements against Jews, with anti-Israel sentiment being only a part of it."

-Rabbi David Nesenoff


Gaza Flotilla Incident

May 31, 2010 at 3:58 PM

We usually stay away from commenting on politics. However, the Gaza Flotilla incident which occurred last night (March 31st, 2010) has sparked an outcry around the world.

With critiques of the actual blockade aside, members of a foreign military are allowed to board any ship entering a militarized zone. And international understanding is that peaceful activists must not respond violently. After all, according to JPost, the first 5 of the 9 vessels were allowed to proceed peacefully after consenting to searches by the Israeli Navy. Why did this ship (the 6th one) react differently?

Although the details are still being released (and we reserve the right to change our own minds as new evidence comes forth) we feel it is vitally important to watch exactly what happened.

The IDF gave warnings to the Gaza Flotilla prior to their being boarded:




Here is up-close footage of IDF Navy soldiers being attacked as they board the vessel:




Here is an aerial view of the same situation (the 'peace activists' attacking soldiers as they board the vessel):



Points to Consider:

1) Not expecting the level of violence, Israeli soldiers were armed with paint-ball guns (they were also carrying small side-arms in case things got out of hand). But NO machine guns! They were not prepared for a battle, but crowd control.

2) The first 5 vessels were allowed to proceed peacefully after consenting to being searched by the Israeli Navy.

3) Many passengers aboard the ship were already riled-up and singing about killing Jews BEFORE the soldiers arrived.

4) If this was an attack by Israel against the ship, shouldn't there be even more casualties than only 10? (Sounds like IDF soldiers actually did a good job controlling the situation after they were attacked)


So decide for yourself. Did Israel overreact?



Yeshiva Hero or Moral Zero?

Jul 13, 2009 at 2:30 PM


An article in the Jerusalem Post today reports that Israel's Supreme Court has harshly criticized Jerusalem District Court Judge Moshe Drori for his acquittal of a yeshiva bochur who intentionally ran over an Ethiopian-Israeli parking attendant.

In January 2006, Noga Zoarish was working as a cashier in a parking lot in Jerusalem. The haredi driver, who aspires to become a rabbinical judge attempted to leave the parking lot without paying. Zoarish blocked the car's exit with her body. But the driver proceeded, intentionally hitting the woman and lifting her onto the hood of the car and carrying her 15 meters before knocking her to the ground. Zoarish lost consciousness from the impact and sustained head injuries.

The driver attempted to deny the incident until he was confronted with video from a security camera installed at the scene of the hit and run. Additionally, the driver was driving with a revoked license and had a previous conviction for theft.

What makes this incident even more frustrating is the cover-up within the haredi world. The yeshiva bochur brought to the court recommendations from Chief Sephardi Rabbi Shlomo Amar and Shas spiritual mentor Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, asking Drori to be lenient, claiming that an excessively stringent ruling that constituted moral turpitude would block him from being appointed as a judge in the rabbinical courts, which is a public office.

In my humble opinion ... this yeshiva bochur should be barred from being a dayan (a judge on a rabbinical court - a Beis Din). A dayan must not only be able to interpret halachah, but be able to apply it to real people and real situations. People are the real issue - as we are all created b'tzelem Elokim (in the image of G-d), and apparently "people" are something this bochur has missed. You CANNOT intentionally run someone over and then expect to sit on a Beis Din!

A dayan must indeed be an upstanding mensch with moral turpitude. Is this really the rabbinic judge you want to decide your case? Based on the driver's previous conviction of theft, his driving without a license, a hit-and-run, and initial denial, it seems moral turpitude is something this guy lacks. He should certainly have his rabbinical aspirations squelched. This is a major Chillul HaShem (a desecration of G-d's Name).

People come first. This is the ethic of Yeshua, and the basic understanding of all halachah.

Is Obama "Good" for Israel?

May 17, 2009 at 3:27 PM


There has been plenty of nervous chatter and hand wringing concerning how President Obama may or may not alter the U.S.'s position towards Israel and specifically the (ongoing and usually unproductive) peace process.  We are very interested in seeing how his upcoming meetings with Arab and Israeli leaders are handled, especially his upcoming meeting with Netanyahu tomorrow.  

As discussed in this article in today's New York Times, Obama's background may be very positive (or could at least lead to a change of pace).  Obviously, the United States' approach for the last 10 -15 years has not worked.  

Mr. Obama’s predecessors, Presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush, came of age politically with the American-Israeli viewpoint of the Middle East conflict as their primary tutor, said Daniel Levy, a former Israeli peace negotiator. While each often expressed concern and empathy for the Palestinians — with Mr. Clinton, in particular, pushing hard for Middle East peace during the last months of his presidency — their early perspectives were shaped more by Israelis and American Jews than by Muslims, Mr. Levy said.

It is indeed time to bring additional considerations to the table.  Although we do not expect the facts on the ground to actually change all that much, it's pretty pessimistic to throw up our hands and call it an "intractable conflict."  

Although it is inconvenient to admit as much, the Palestinians have been handed a raw deal.  By their fellow Arabs, by their own leaders, and yes, even by the government of Israel.  It is important to recognize the legitimacy of their concerns, for they, too, are created "in the image of G-d."  President Obama (who one of us voted for, and one of us did not) may have the personal background and perspective that's needed to broker something slightly better than absolute stalemate.

P.S.:  We weren't born yesterday and are well aware that Israel/Palestinian issues inspire particularly vivid reactions, several of which we share simultaneously within our own little skulls.  By all means, put your insights and venom in the comments section below. 

Jerusalem as Sacred Space

May 14, 2009 at 6:04 AM


Abstract of Makom Kadosh: Jerusalem as Sacred Space by Rabbi Joshua Brumbach. For the full article, click here.

How is it that Jerusalem became an axis of sacred space, a locus of the divine presence on earth? It lacks a harbor, access to a trade route, even interesting topography! And yet it is considered one of the most holy cities. As Scripture reveals, Jerusalem is sacred because G-d willed it to be, through various associated hierophonies, or divine encounters.

Beginning in Genesis, the Jewish patriarch Abraham (then Avram) goes up the Shaveh Valley, where he meets Melchizedek, the King of Shalem (present-day Jerusalem) and a priest of the G-d Most High. (Genesis 14:17-20) Avram eats a covenant meal with him there, Melchizedek blesses Avram, and Avram gives Melchizedek a tithe of ten percent of all his possessions.

In Genesis 22, a passage known in Hebrew as the Akeida, G-d calls Abraham to take his son Isaac to Mt. Moriah, and build an altar there on top the mountain. He binds up his son Isaac, and lays him upon the wood on top the altar. As Abraham is about to slay his son, he is stopped by an angel of G-d. 2 Chronicles 3:1-2 later identifies Mt. Moriah as the Temple Mount in Jerusalem.

In 2 Samuel 24, G-d sends a plague upon the people of Israel as punishment against King David. 70,000 people die. At the end of the specified time, an angel of G-d stands atop the threshing floor of Aravnah, in the home of a Jebusite whose city was captured by David, and later renamed "Jerusalem." King David buys the site, builds an altar there, and offers sacrifices to G-d. G-d lifts the plague, and the site of King David's altar is later identified by 2 Chronicles 3 as the Temple Mount in Jerusalem.

Put on an ancient near eastern thinking cap (which understands space as neither fungible nor homogenous) and connect the dots. Jerusalem plays host to ... the creation story in Genesis, godly figures like Melchizedek, the beloved Mt. Moriah of Abraham, and the place of G-d's revelation to King David! Is it any wonder that the Temple Mount is now associated with the physical manifestation of G-d's presence on earth??